Seven years between records can easily kill a band's momentum. Most groups return softened by age, overproducing their tracks to cover up the lost friction. Instead, The Twilight Sad came back leaner, heavier, and visibly bruised. Across these tracks, there is no studio fat—just massive walls of modulation anchored by a rhythm section that hits like wet concrete.
James Graham’s delivery remains completely unvarnished. He doesn't smooth over his thick Scottish brogue or rely on pitch-correction safety nets. When his voice cracks on 'CHEST WOUND TO THE CHEST', the mix leaves it completely exposed at the front, scraping against Andy MacFarlane’s chorused Telecaster chords. It sounds claustrophobic, physical, and genuinely uncomfortable. That is the entire point.
"When the final crescendo lands, it doesn't sound like a tidy Pro Tools session—it sounds like four people in a cold tracking room driving tube amplifiers until the speakers rattle."
On 'GET AWAY FROM IT ALL', the low-end work between the bass and kick drum operates with zero polite distance. Alex MacKay’s bass doesn't just trace root notes beneath the noise; it drives the harmonic weight forward, leaving just enough dynamic headroom so the high-frequency cymbal wash doesn't collapse into digital fizz. The track breathes through volume shifts rather than synth layers.
Then comes 'TV PEOPLE STILL THROWING TVS AT PEOPLE', which stretches out without ever wandering into self-indulgent post-rock theater. The distortion builds steadily through repetition, relying on harsh pickup attacks and analog decay. When the final crescendo lands, it doesn't sound like a tidy Pro Tools session—it sounds like four people in a cold tracking room driving tube amplifiers until the speakers rattle.
IT'S THE LONG GOODBYE offers zero pop compromises and no background music for casual playlists. It is abrasive, exhausting, and completely vital.
Walter Andrade is the founder and lead critic at Cross-Rhythm, writing on organic rhythm dynamics, non-linear songwriting, and analog studio acoustics.